Skip to main content

On DSLs and design patterns

Through an article on InfoQ I have come across a number of blog posts about DSLs (domain specific languages). It all starts with Joel (by now famous for his opinions on Ruby performance ;) ) who explains the rationale behind creating Wasabi, a DSL for his company's bug tracker. This software apparently has to run on VB and PHP.

InfoQ also refers to the blog "discipline and punish" (what a name) in which the author argues that DSLs are flawed due to their (or rather their creator's) inability to adapt to change - well, that's what I gather from it at least.

Personally, I am currently working for a company that has created its own DSL for describing user interfaces on mobile devices (we're not talking about simple XML, but rather a real language). These UIs need to run cross-platform (Symbian, MS Mobile, Java, etc) so the DSL really has to abstract the platform differences. So in essence, I really buy into Joel's argument that DSLs are about abstraction (I do NOT buy into his argument that Wasabi is a good idea for the reasons he describes or that creating a DSL would be not a lot of effort).

One thing that had not been covered on the DSL discussion as mentioned by InfoQ is the tools issue. If you create a DSL you either have to develop without tools (-> inefficient) or create your own tools (-> effort). For me, this is one of the reasons why I do think twice about creating a DSL and then think about it again.

And now to something completely different.

In this blog entry Mark Dominus argues that design patterns are a sign for a weakness in the language. Thought about it. Found it a brilliant observation. Agree. (and I'm sure Erich Gamma will not be happy ; )

Maybe there will always be design patterns because the mainstream general purpose languages changes so slowly (i.e. our change from one to the other). So we stick with them for a while (like a decade) until we learned enough to convert to a new general purpose language (think C, C++, Java).

Along these lines I remembered that the decorator pattern can be implemented really easily in Ruby. But still, it has to be implemented. So, maybe Ruby is not the great next thing after Java (it's just nice - which is good enough for me ;) ).

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Python script to set genre in iTunes with Last.fm tags

Now that I have started to seriously use iTunes I figured it might be nice to have the genre tag set in a meaningful way. Since I have a reasonably large collection of mp3s doing that manually was out of question - I wrote me a Python script to do that. There seems to be a large demand for such a functionality (at least I found a lot of questions on how to automatically set the genre tag) so maybe someone else finds the script useful. It is pasted below. General Strategy The basic idea is to use Last.fm's tags for genre tagging. In iTunes the genre tag is IMO best used when it only contains one single genre, i.e. something like "Electronica", not something like "Electronica / Dance". On the other hand dropping all but one tag would lose a lot of information, so I decided to use the groupings tag for additional information that is contained in the list of tags that an artist has on Last.fm. In the example above that would be something like "Electronica, Dan...
15 comments
Read more

CMS vendors now and then

CMS analyst Janus Boye has just published a post on CMS vendors that discontinue their products (because they get bought out or similar) During the past 10 years, a number of software products used by online professionals have been discontinued That sentence reminded me that I had given a talk almost 10 years ago (it was in 2001 exactly) that contained a slide on the CMS market at that time: The circles denote vendors that were part of CMS market overview articles by popular German IT magazines in that year (I wanted to show how differently the market place could be perceived). A vendor placed in any of the circles had enough attention to be part of at least one evaluation. The vendors outside of the circles were not part of any of these overview articles, but somehow present in the market place - at least I knew their names back then. It is interesting to look at the landscape from that time. Of course there are a number of well-known vendors that got bought (Vignette, Obtree, Gauss...
2 comments
Read more

Note on running Apache OpenWhisk actions locally for development

When you develop an action for Apache OpenWhisk it can become cumbersome and time-consuming to upload the action to your OpenWhisk instance in order to test it. This is especially the case when your (Node-based) action contains NPM dependencies. You can always use Node.js to run the action locally. However, ideally one wants to run in an environment as similar to the cloud as possible - in this case run within an OpenWhisk Docker image. This is where runtest.sh comes in handy: it does exactly this - run the action locally in an OpenWhisk container. I hope this tool will make it into wsk or a similar tool for local OpenWhisk action development.
Post a Comment
Read more